How Healthy You Feel Depends on Where You Live
Would you guess that people in some developing nations report feeling healthier than people in some of the world's wealthiest countries?
Religious Differences in Physical and Mental Health among Israeli Jews: Findings from the Global Flourishing Study
Among Israeli Jews, there is a consistent gradient where higher levels of religious observance are associated with better self-reported physical health, mental health, and overall well-being.
The positive association between religiousness and health persists even after accounting for demographic and socioeconomic factors like age, sex, income, and education.
This linear relationship, where the most religious groups report the best health, contrasts with older research from 2004 that found a U-shaped curve where both secular and ultra-Orthodox Jews had better health than those in the middle.
This research offers crucial insights for Israeli society and beyond. For healthcare planners and policymakers in Israel, understanding that different religious groups report vastly different health outcomes can help direct resources more effectively. For doctors and therapists, these findings challenge potential stereotypes that a highly religious life is inherently stressful or psychologically burdensome; in fact, the data suggests the opposite may be true for this population, which could improve patient care.
“As Israel's most religious groups grow, their distinct health outcomes have major implications for the nation's future well-being.”
More broadly, the study provides a counter-narrative to common assumptions about ultra-Orthodox communities, which are often viewed from the outside as isolated or struggling. Instead, this research shows they report the highest levels of happiness and life satisfaction. As the most religious segments of Israeli society are also the fastest-growing, these findings have significant implications for the future of the nation's overall public health and well-being.
“As Israel's most religious groups grow, their distinct health outcomes have major implications for the nation's future well-being.”
Does a person's level of religious observance affect their well-being? A new study from the Global Flourishing Study explored this question within Israel, surveying nearly 3,000 Jewish adults. Participants identified with one of five groups, ranging from secular (hiloni) to ultra-Orthodox (charedi).
“Moving from secular to ultra-Orthodox, Jewish Israelis report steadily higher life satisfaction and steadily lower anxiety and pain.”
Researchers then asked them about nine different aspects of their lives, including physical health, mental health, happiness, life satisfaction, depression, anxiety, and pain. The results revealed a striking and consistent pattern. For eight of the nine measures, well-being improved in a stepwise fashion along the spectrum of religious observance. As people's religious identity moved from secular to traditional to Orthodox, their self-reported levels of happiness, life satisfaction, and overall health steadily increased.
At the same time, their reported feelings of depression, anxiety, bodily pain, and general suffering steadily decreased. The ultra-Orthodox (charedi) group reported the highest levels of well-being and the lowest levels of distress overall. This 'dose-response' relationship, where more religious observance was linked to better outcomes, remained strong even after scientists accounted for other factors that influence health, like age, income, gender, and marital status. The study doesn't say that religion *causes* better health, but it uncovers a powerful connection between religious identity and a flourishing life for Jewish adults in Israel.
On a 10-point scale, ultra-Orthodox (charedi) Jews reported life satisfaction scores that were, on average, 1.8 points higher than those of secular (hiloni) Jews.
Secular (hiloni) Jews reported average depression scores 1.45 times higher than those reported by ultra-Orthodox (charedi) Jews.
Only 4% of ultra-Orthodox (charedi) Jews reported having health problems that restrict activity, compared to 13% of secular (hiloni) Jews.
On a 10-point scale, ultra-Orthodox (charedi) Jews reported mental health scores 1.2 points higher on average than secular (hiloni) Jews.
Levin, J., Bradshaw, M., & Johnson, B. R. (2024). Religious Differences in Physical and Mental Health among Israeli Jews: Findings from the Global Flourishing Study. Journal of Religion and Health, 63(4), 2544–2558. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-024-02078-5
Would you guess that people in some developing nations report feeling healthier than people in some of the world's wealthiest countries?
A country with very few smokers can still have a major smoking problem.
The physical pain you feel today might have roots in events that happened decades ago, when you were a child.
Where you live might determine how much you hurt: people in Egypt are more than twice as likely to report being in pain as those in Israel.
Did you know that attending religious services as a child is linked to how much you exercise as an adult?
Experiencing abuse as a child increases the risk of life-limiting health problems in adulthood by nearly 60%.